Home » Methods for Screening Candidates: Build a Hiring Process That Finds the Right Fit

Methods for Screening Candidates: Build a Hiring Process That Finds the Right Fit

A bad hire will waste your company’s time, money, and trust. A good hire will contribute to the growth of your team. Therefore, you need to go beyond just scanning candidate resumes during your hiring process.

Employers can use the best methods for screening candidates to evaluate candidates’ ability to perform a role based on their skill set, prior work history, and how well they would fit within the organization. In addition, having an established process will make it easier for both parties (employer and applicant) to complete the hiring process.

Start With the Job, Not the Resume

Before evaluating applicant’s submissions, establish how you will measure whether an individual has achieved “success” within the specified position. Identify those abilities (skills), background (experience), and personal attributes (traits) which are required for an applicant to be successful.

This will help focus the process and decrease bias by separating what is necessary for the position from what could be learned at a later date.

Use a Screening Funnel

The process is a series of steps to help reduce the number of applicants while still considering the most qualified ones.

Stage 1: Resume and Application Review

Review all applications using the same job requirements. Search for related experience, skills, and clearly demonstrated past work.

Avoid assessing candidates based on personal data which is unrelated to the job requirements.

Stage 2: Short Phone or Video Call

A short telephone conversation can verify critical information prior to a longer interview. Find out about the applicant’s interest, when they are available, and their applicable experience.

Use the exact same base question for all applicants. This will make it much simpler to compare the responses.

Stage 3: Skills Assessment

A real-world project is an indication that the candidate has the ability to complete the work required. An example would be if a writing position included a brief writing assignment and/or a technical position using a real world scenario where the candidate would have to solve a problem.

Keep tests reasonable in length and tied to real job duties.

Stage 4: Structured Interview

Develop assessment questions based on the candidate’s required job skills. Have the candidate provide examples of how he/she responded to actual work-related issues.

A basic grading rubric should be utilized to assess each candidate’s response. The assessment system allows the recruiting team to evaluate candidates using factual information instead of using subjective opinions.

Keep the Process Fair and Useful

The best methods for screening candidates need to be consistent, accessible and relate directly to the candidate’s potential employment. Candidates must receive clear directions about the process and understand how each step works.

A few good practices can improve the process:

  • Use the same criteria for every applicant.
  • Keep notes based on facts and examples.
  • Protect candidate data.
  • Tell applicants when they can expect an update.

Make Better Decisions With Clear Evidence

Screening is most effective when each phase of screening addresses a different question. Does the candidate fulfill the minimum qualifications? Are they capable of performing the job? Do we believe that the candidate will be able to perform well in this position and with this team?

Using a clearly defined process and evaluating evidence throughout each phase of the hiring process will allow employers to better assess which candidate is best suited for their position, as well as enhance the experience for all applicants.

back to top